Traffic Lab Model info

How do three-to-two and two-to-one lane drops compare?

At a desired speed of 80 km/h, 72 vehicles passed the two-lane bridge bottleneck in its busiest simulated minute and 35 passed the one-lane bottleneck.1

Overhead view of cars and a truck on parallel motorway lanes.
Illustrative photo · Bernd Dittrich / Unsplash

The difference in the model

The busiest minutes at the two bottlenecks differed by 37 vehicles. Each baseline keeps the same number of approach lanes open across the bridge.2

Vehicles in the busiest minute at a desired speed of 80 km/h2
LanesNo lane dropLane dropChange
3 → 29872−27%
2 → 16535−46%

What other studies found

In a US work zone simulation by Beacher and colleagues, mean throughput was around 2,304 vehicles per hour for a three-to-two drop and 1,269 for two to one. These are averages across several settings with conventional US work zone traffic control.3

At a three-to-two lane drop on the UK’s M4, Bertini and Leal measured an average 9.7% lower outflow after the queue formed than immediately before it. The field study compared two phases at the same bottleneck.4

What the busiest minute does not show

The busiest minute is a snapshot. It says nothing about how many vehicles cross over a whole day or how long individual drivers wait. It is still a fair comparison between these two bottlenecks because both runs use the same approach and demand.

Try it yourself

Start both runs with the same traffic demand and a desired speed of 80 km/h. Compare the count at the end of the bridge and see how far each queue extends.

Isometric simulation view of cars merging from three lanes into two before the river bridge.
Starting conditions in the simulator · 3 → 2 · 80 km/h

Sources

  1. Traffic Lab · Highway simulator throughput matrix ↩
  2. Traffic Lab · Simulation dataset (JSON) ↩↩2
  3. Beacher et al. (2004) · Simulated lane configurations, Tables 11 and 12, pp. 23-24 ↩
  4. Bertini and Leal (2005) · Flow before and after queuing, Table 3 ↩