Traffic Lab Model info

What happens to local sales when a street is pedestrianised?

On Munich’s Sendlinger Straße and two side streets, 67% of businesses that answered the sales question reported unchanged sales.1 In Valencia, card sales after pedestrianisation fared better than in comparable areas where many cafés and restaurants were clustered. Where there were few, sales did worse.2

What Munich businesses reported

In January 2017, six months into the trial, the evaluators surveyed businesses on Sendlinger Straße and two side streets. Of the 82 that answered the sales question, 67% reported stable sales and about 11% an increase; a few reported steep losses. These are the businesses’ own assessments. How much the scheme, the weather and online shopping contributed remains open.1

What card payments revealed in Valencia

A Spanish study compared small areas that gained pedestrian space in 2011 with similar areas that kept their layout. It used card payments recorded by BBVA before and after the change. That let the researchers account for sales rising elsewhere in the city over the same period.2

Where cafés and restaurants were most concentrated, card sales fared better than in the comparison areas. Where there were few, the redesigned areas did worse. For shops selling everyday goods, the researchers found no clear statistical difference. Cash payments are missing from the data. And area totals say nothing about one bakery.2

What is known about 30 km/h and sales

The studies reviewed here give no reliable sales estimate for a street that drops from 50 to 30 km/h and stays open to cars. A Swiss study of 30 km/h zones tracked the number of people employed. It cannot show how much customers spent.3

Test it in the simulator

Lower demand in the city model and watch traffic at the junctions fall.

Sources

  1. Studio Stadt Region and Zebralog (2017) · Sendlinger Straße pedestrianisation trial, pp. 18 and 25 (German) ↩↩2
  2. Yoshimura et al. (2022) · Pedestrianisation and sales in Spanish cities, Methodology and Fig. 8 ↩↩2↩3
  3. Swiss research report 1655 (2019) · Employment effects of traffic calming in town centres, Chapter 3 (German) ↩