Traffic Lab Model info

How much more traffic can a late zipper merge handle than an early merge on German motorways?

The throughput gain at German motorway work zones remains uncertain. Signs encouraging a late merge changed how drivers used the lanes in two US field trials. The findings on throughput depend on the site and how the comparison was made.12

A yellow “Prepare to stop” sign at the approach to roadworks.
Illustrative photo · Ziph / Unsplash

Two US field trials where two lanes narrowed to one

In Michigan, signs activated during congestion asked drivers to use both lanes up to the taper and take turns merging there. The I-94 comparison used opposite directions that also differed in truck traffic. The study had no baseline measurements for the direction with the new signs. The figures are from congested afternoon peaks.1

In Tappahannock, Virginia, researchers changed the signs at the same site. The work zone was on a main road with traffic signals and access points. The study found no statistically significant difference in throughput or time spent in the queue there.2

Standard work zone signs and signs encouraging a late merge
MeasureStandardLate
Michigan · Average flow1990 veh/h1,207 veh/h
Michigan · Merges at taper1≈ 49%66%
Virginia · Share in ending lane233.7%38.8%

What a German figure needs

Using both approach lanes gives waiting vehicles more space. Throughput measures how many vehicles pass through the bottleneck in an hour. German work zones lack comparable measurements of both strategies under similar layouts, demand and vehicle mix.12

Test it in the simulator

Compare early merging with a zipper merge at the lane end.

Sources

  1. Datta et al. (2007) · Michigan DOT report RC-1500, Executive Summary, Sections 4-5 and 11, Table 25, p. 55 ↩↩2↩3↩4↩5
  2. Beacher et al. (2004) · VTRC report 05-R6, Tappahannock field trial, pp. 52-53 and 55-56 ↩↩2↩3↩4