Traffic Lab Model info

Do bike lanes slow down ambulances, fire crews or police?

Before-and-after data show different changes across services. After two Toronto street redesigns with protected bike lanes, paramedic response times rose less near the projects than citywide. For the fire service, the 90th percentile of travel time rose more locally than in the respective comparison area.12

A cyclist crosses a green-painted cycle crossing at a street corner.
Illustrative photo · Andra C Taylor Jr / Unsplash

What Toronto measured before and after the redesigns

For Yonge Street, Toronto compared January through October in 2019 and 2022. The paramedic clock ran from the time the ambulance dispatch centre answered the call until an ambulance unit reached the scene. The analysis covered life-threatening calls within 1,000 m of the corridor. Fire crews measured travel from departure to arrival at the scene in a smaller area. In 90% of cases the measured time is at or below the 90th percentile.1

On Bloor Street West, the paramedic service compared 10 July to 10 September 2023 with 10 October to 10 December 2023. The city leaves the start of its response time measure unspecified. The fire service compared October through December in 2022 and 2023 and measured travel time for the first fire truck to arrive. Both services analysed a 500 m area around the corridor.2

The comparison figures are citywide. The Yonge Street fire service comparison uses the rest of the city.12

Changes in emergency response measures in Toronto
MeasureLocalComparison
Yonge · Paramedic response, 90th percentile1+85 s+121 s
Yonge · Fire travel, 90th percentile1+49 s+41 s
Bloor West · Paramedic response, mean2+42 s+45 s
Bloor West · Fire travel, 90th percentile2+30 s+2 s

What the redesigns can tell us

Toronto’s projects also changed features such as turn lanes and the allocation of road space. The reports give times for incidents in the surrounding areas. Which emergency vehicles drove along the redesigned streets remains unclear. Ottawa reported broadly stable response times during its Laurier Avenue West pilot with concrete separators.123

The evaluations leave open how painted lanes and physically protected lanes compare. They provide no separate series of police response times.123

Test it in the simulator

Dispatch an emergency vehicle in the city model and watch it cross the junctions.

Sources

  1. City of Toronto (2023) · ActiveTO Midtown on Yonge Street, pp. 22-23, Tables 8-9 ↩↩2↩3↩4↩5↩6↩7
  2. City of Toronto (2024) · Bloor Street West interim report, p. 2, Phase 1 and Fire and Paramedic Services ↩↩2↩3↩4↩5↩6↩7
  3. City of Ottawa · Laurier Avenue West overview, results of the two-year pilot from 2011 to 2013 ↩↩2