# How do three-to-two and two-to-one lane drops compare?

At a desired speed of 80 km/h, **72 vehicles** passed the two-lane bridge bottleneck in its busiest simulated minute and **35** passed the one-lane bottleneck.[^1]

[HTML version](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/three-to-two-vs-two-to-one-lanes/)

![Overhead view of cars and a truck on parallel motorway lanes.](https://onemorelane.org/photos/lanes-960.webp)

Illustrative photo · [Bernd Dittrich / Unsplash](https://unsplash.com/photos/W0A8qmTS8IU)

## The difference in the model

The busiest minutes at the two bottlenecks differed by 37 vehicles. Each baseline keeps the same number of approach lanes open across the bridge.[^2]

Vehicles in the busiest minute at a desired speed of 80 km/h[^2]

| Lanes | No lane drop | Lane drop | Change |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| 3 → 2 | 98 | 72 | **−27%** |
| 2 → 1 | 65 | 35 | **−46%** |

## What other studies found

In a US work zone simulation by Beacher and colleagues, mean throughput was around **2,304 vehicles per hour** for a three-to-two drop and **1,269** for two to one. These are averages across several settings with conventional US work zone traffic control.[^3]

At a three-to-two lane drop on the UK’s M4, Bertini and Leal measured an average **9.7% lower outflow** after the queue formed than immediately before it. The field study compared two phases at the same bottleneck.[^4]

## What the busiest minute does not show

The busiest minute is a snapshot. It says nothing about how many vehicles cross over a whole day or how long individual drivers wait. It is still a fair comparison between these two bottlenecks because both runs use the same approach and demand.

## Try it yourself

Start both runs with the same traffic demand and a desired speed of 80 km/h. Compare the count at the end of the bridge and see how far each queue extends.

- [3 → 2 · 80 km/h](https://onemorelane.org/en/highway/?map=highway&preset=custom&seed=1187&lanes=3&exitLanes=2&speed=80&attention=80&demand=160&style=balanced&extended=0)
- [2 → 1 · 80 km/h](https://onemorelane.org/en/highway/?map=highway&preset=custom&seed=1187&lanes=2&exitLanes=1&speed=80&attention=80&demand=160&style=balanced&extended=0)

![Isometric simulation view of cars merging from three lanes into two before the river bridge.](https://onemorelane.org/faq-preview-3-2-80.webp)

## Related questions

- [How much traffic gets through when four highway lanes narrow to three, two or one?](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/four-lanes-narrowing-to-three-two-or-one/index.md)
- [How much do extra approach lanes help when the bridge still has one lane?](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/more-approach-lanes-one-bridge-lane/index.md)
- [What is a capacity drop after a queue forms, and how big was it on the M4?](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/capacity-drop-after-queue-formation-m4/index.md)

## Sources

[^1]: [Traffic Lab · Highway simulator throughput matrix](https://onemorelane.org/en/highway/#durchsatz)
[^2]: [Traffic Lab · Simulation dataset (JSON)](https://onemorelane.org/capacity-data.json)
[^3]: [Beacher et al. (2004) · Simulated lane configurations, Tables 11 and 12, pp. 23-24](https://rosap.ntl.bts.gov/view/dot/19648/dot_19648_DS1.pdf#page=25)
[^4]: [Bertini and Leal (2005) · Flow before and after queuing, Table 3](https://doi.org/10.1061/%28ASCE%290733-947X%282005%29131%3A6%28397%29)
