# Can a third lane help if the highway narrows back to two lanes?

Changing the layout can **spread traffic more evenly across lanes**. In Japan’s Kobotoke Tunnel trial, flow just before congestion was slightly higher at the two-lane bottleneck. The difference lacked statistical significance.[^1]

[HTML version](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/third-lane-before-a-two-lane-bottleneck/)

![Aerial view of crossing highways and curved connecting ramps.](https://onemorelane.org/photos/junction-960.webp)

Illustrative photo · [Emmanuel Appiah / Unsplash](https://unsplash.com/photos/Ry5z_fFKjFg)

## How lane use changed

On the Chūō Expressway toward Tokyo, an existing climbing lane became a regular traffic lane. The three-lane section opened with a new lane next to the median and ended with the outer lane tapering out. In the 15-minute periods before congestion that the study compared, the outer lane at observation point C carried 4.0% of traffic before the trial. During the trial, the inner, middle and outer lanes at the same point carried 21.2%, 42.4% and 36.4%, respectively.[^1]

## How much traffic passed through the bottleneck

The bottleneck was on the two-lane stretch beyond the lane drop. The researchers compared detector readings from 23 days with congestion before the trial and 11 days with congestion during its first three months. The values in the table use five-minute detector data.[^1]

Average flow at the two-lane bottleneck in vehicles per hour[^1]

| Traffic conditions | Before the trial | During the trial |
| --- | ---: | ---: |
| Before congestion | 2,775 | 2,841 |
| During congestion | 2,480 | 2,530 |

## How the researchers estimated the change in congestion

On seven trial days without crashes or other incidents, the queue length accumulated over time was 17.8% below the researchers’ estimate for the previous layout. That comparison depends in part on the assumed changes in capacity.[^1]

The extra lane first changes how traffic is distributed on the approach. Whether that raises discharge at the tunnel shows up in the detector comparison. The estimated queue reduction is a third step and holds only under the study’s assumptions.

## Try it yourself

Compare a single lane with a short second lane (1 → 2 → 1) at identical arrivals. Watch queue length, exits and time lost.

- [Try the short second lane](https://onemorelane.org/en/short-lane/)

## Related questions

- [Where does the extra traffic come from after a road is widened, and how can my trip still get quicker?](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/do-more-highway-lanes-induce-demand/index.md)
- [Should an auxiliary lane end before or after the next highway entrance ramp?](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/where-should-an-auxiliary-lane-end/index.md)
- [Can a new shortcut slow everyone down? What does Berlin’s A100 show?](https://onemorelane.org/en/faq/braess-paradox-berlin-a100/index.md)

## Sources

[^1]: [Moriyama et al. (2011) · Kobotoke field trial, pp. 37-38, Fig. 2, pp. 42-43, Tables 3-4 and Fig. 7, pp. 46-47, Tables 7-8](https://www.researchgate.net/publication/251713982_The_Effect_on_Lane_Utilization_and_Traffic_Capacity_of_Adding_an_Auxiliary_Lane)
